What is paradox of warning: In intelligence, there's a phenomenon called "the paradox of warning." This is when you warn the This article originally appeared onFortune.com. Really! Hobbes described opposition to this morally requisite transition as arising from universal diffidence, the mutual mistrust between individuals, coupled with the misguided belief of each in his or her own superiority. written by RSI Security November 10, 2021. Warning Number. This approach makes perfect sense, considering the constant refrain across the security vendor landscape that its not if, but when an attack will succeed. Thus, the prospective solution to the new vulnerabilities would paradoxically impede one of the main present benefits of these cyber alternatives to conventional banking and finance. x3T0 BC=S3#]=csS\B.C=CK3$6D*k The cybersecurity industry is nothing if not crowded. The control of such malevolent actors and the provision of security against their actions is not primarily a matter of ethics or moral argument (although important moral issues, such as interrogation, torture and capital punishment, do arise in the pursuit of law enforcement). Management can also benefit from better prevention over time, analyzing the value of their entire security investment, optimizing both technology and resource allocations, with a focus on process improvements rather than constant repair and recovery. At the same time, readers and critics had been mystified by my earlier warnings regarding SSH. This involves a focus on technologies aimed at shrinking attacker dwell time to limit the impact of the inevitable attack. The device is not designed to operate through the owners password-protected home wireless router. There is a paradox in the quest for cybersecurity which lies at the heart of the polemics around whether or not Apple should help the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) break the encryption on an iPhone used by the pro-Islamic State killers in San Bernardino. Yet more often than not, attendees are likely to leave a conference awash with brochures all promising to deliver very similar, if not the same, benefits. In October 2016, precisely such a botnet constructed of IoT devices was used to attack Twitter, Facebook and other social media along with large swaths of the Internet itself, using a virus known as Mirai to launch crippling DDoS attacks on key sites, including Oracles DYN site, the principal source of optimised Domain Name Servers and the source of dynamic Internet protocol addresses for applications such as Netflix and LinkedIn. How stupid were we victims capable of being? Meanwhile, the advent of quantum computing (QC) technology is liable to have an enormous impact on data storage and encryption capacities. Instead of enhancing cyber-security, - as the $4 billion budget outlay for intelligence agencies is named - at least a quarter of . Meanwhile, its cybersecurity arm has seen 40% growth year on year, withrevenues reaching $10 billion. What I mean is this: technically, almost any mechanical or electrical device can be connected to the Internet: refrigerators, toasters, voice assistants like Alexa and Echo, smart TVs and DVRs, dolls, cloud puppets and other toys, baby monitors, swimming pools, automobiles and closed-circuit cameras in the otherwise-secure corporate board roomsbut should they be? Law, on Aristotles account, defines the minimum standard of acceptable social behaviour, while ethics deals with aspirations, ideals and excellences that require a lifetime to master. But while this may appear a noble endeavour, all is not quite as it seems. As Miller and Bossomaier note in their discussion of that work, I made no pretence of taking on the broader issues of crime, vandalism or general cybersecurity. PubMedGoogle Scholar, UZH Digital Society Initiative, Zrich, Switzerland, Digital Society Initiative University of Zurich, Zrich, Switzerland. l-. Some of that malware stayed there for months before being taken down. This is a very stubborn illustration of widespread diffidence on the part of cyber denizens. Get deeper insight with on-call, personalized assistance from our expert team. And over time, smaller but well-connected communities may be more effective at preventing and identifying terrorist threats among their members. In this essay, I set out a case that our cybersecurity community is its own worst enemy, and that our security dilemmas, including serious moral dilemmas, have arisen mostly because of our flawed assumptions and methodology (modus operandi). Part of the National Cybersecurity Authority (NCA) Google Scholar, Lucas G (2017) The ethics of cyber warfare. Cybersecurity Risk Paradox Cybersecurity policy & resilience | Whitepaper Around the globe, societies are becoming increasingly dependent on ICT, as it is driving rapid social, economic, and governmental development. Henry Kissinger According to FCA reports, data breaches at financial services companies have increased by over 1,000 percent between 2017 and 2018. People are not only the biggest problem and security risk but also the best tool in defending against an attack. We can all go home now, trusting organizations are now secure. Even apart from the moral conundrums of outright warfare, the cyber domain in general is often described as a lawless frontier or a state of nature (in Hobbess sense), in which everyone seems capable in principle of doing whatever they wish to whomever they please without fear of attribution, retribution or accountability. /Type /XObject Like all relatively ungoverned frontiers, however, this Rousseauvian bliss is shattered by the malevolent behaviour of even a few bad actorsand there are more than a few of these in the cyber domain. Malicious messages sent from Office 365 targeted almost60 million users in 2020. State-sponsored hacktivism had indeed, by that time, become the norm. The major fear was the enhanced ability of rogue states and terrorists to destroy dams, disrupt national power grids, and interfere with transportation and commerce in a manner that would, in their devastation, destruction and loss of human life, rival conventional full-scale armed conflict (see also Chap. I had just finished a 7-year stint in federal security service, teaching and writing on this topic for the members of that community, evidently to no avail. Zack Whittaker for Zero Day (5 April 2018): https://www.zdnet.com/article/new-mirai-style-botnet-targets-the-financial-sector/ (last access July 7 2019). Paradox of warning. Target Sector. The private firms have been understandably reluctant to reveal their own zero-day vulnerabilities in new software and products, lest doing so undermine public confidence in (and marketfor) their products. No one, it seems, knew what I was talking about. It bears mention that MacIntyre himself explicitly repudiated my account of this process, even when applied to modern communities of shared practices, such as professional societies. The joint research with Ponemon could be considered a gloomy picture of security and IT professionals tasked with the enormous responsibility of keeping their organizations secure with a limited budget, facing unlimited threats. But it's not. Get free research and resources to help you protect against threats, build a security culture, and stop ransomware in its tracks. Mark Malloch-Brown on the Ukraine War and Challenges to Open Societies, The Covid-19 Pandemic and Deadly Conflict, https://icg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/2023-02/hero_image_mali_briefing_feb_2023.JPG, https://icg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/2023-02/hero_image_afghanistan_report_feb_2023.JPG, https://icg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/2023-01/wl-ukraine-hero-2023.jpg, https://icg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/2023-02/hero_image_colombia_report_february_2023.jpg, https://icg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/2023-01/palestinian-succession-report.JPG, https://icg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/2022-10/UsCongresshero.jpg, Taliban Restrictions on Womens Rights Deepen Afghanistans Crisis, Keeping the Right Balance in Supporting Ukraine, Protecting Colombias Most Vulnerable on the Road to Total Peace, Managing Palestines Looming Leadership Transition, Stop Fighting Blind: Better Use-of-Force Oversight in the U.S. Congress, Giving Countries in Conflict Their Fair Share of Climate Finance, Floods, Displacement and Violence in South Sudan, Rough Seas: Tracking Maritime Tensions with Iran, Crime in Pieces: The Effects of Mexicos War on Drugs, Explained, How Yemens War Economy Undermines Peace Efforts, The Climate Factor in Nigerias Farmer-Herder Violence, Conflict in Ukraines Donbas: A Visual Explainer, The Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict: A Visual Explainer, Turkeys PKK Conflict: A Visual Explainer, U.N. We need that kind of public-private partnership extended across national boundaries to enable the identification, pursuit and apprehension of malevolent cyber actors, including rogue nations as well as criminals. Disarm BEC, phishing, ransomware, supply chain threats and more. As progressively worse details leak out about the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) breach,. /Filter /FlateDecode There is some commonality among the three . Delivery from a trusted entity is critical to successful ransomware, phishing, and business email compromise attacks. Keep up with the latest news and happenings in the everevolving cybersecurity landscape. But if peace is ultimately what is desired in the cyber domain, our original Hobbesean problem or paradox remains its chief obstacle: namely, how are we to transition from the state of perpetual anarchy, disruption, and the war of all against all within the cyber domain in a manner that will simultaneously ensure individual privacy, security, and public confidence? Not hair on fire incidents, but incidents that require calling in outside help to return to a normal state. In essence, we might characterise the cyber domain as being colonised by libertarians and anarchists who, if they had their way, would continue to dwell in peace and pursue their private and collective interests without interference. Become a channel partner. Participants received emails asking them to upload or download secure documents. It seems more urgent (or at least, less complicated and more interesting) either to discuss all the latest buzz concerning zero-day software vulnerabilities in the IoT, or else to offer moral analysis of specific cases in terms of utility, duty, virtue and those infamous colliding trolley carsmerely substituting, perhaps, driverless, robotic cars for the trolleys (and then wondering, should the autonomous vehicle permit the death of its own passenger when manoeuvring to save the lives of five pedestrians, and so forth). Microsoft has also made many catastrophic architectural decisions. The NSA's budget swelled post-9/11 as it took on a key role in warning U.S. leaders of critical events, combatting terrorism, and conducting cyber-operations. All rights reserved. It also determines that while those countries most in need of cybersecurity gains may often experience early struggles in their digital journey, they can eventually come to enjoy positive outcomes, including the innumerable benefits of greater ICT development. The book itself was actually completed in September 2015. For my part, I have not been impressed with the capacities of our most respected experts, in their turn, to listen and learn from one another, let alone to cooperate or collaborate in order to forge the necessary alliances to promote and foster the peace that Hobbes promised through the imposition of law and order. Stand out and make a difference at one of the world's leading cybersecurity companies. This makes for a rather uncomfortable dichotomy. The hard truth behind Biden's cyber warnings Hackers from Russia and elsewhere have repeatedly breached companies and agencies critical to the nation's welfare. Hundreds of millions of devices around the world could be exposed to a newly revealed software vulnerability, as a senior Biden administration cyber official warned executives from major US . No planes have fallen from the sky as the result of a cyber-attack, nor have chemical plants exploded or dams burst in the interimbut lives have been ruined, elections turned upside down and the possible history of humanity forever altered. We were thus confronted with not one but two legitimate forms of cyber warfare: one waged conventionally by large, resource- and technology-rich nations seeking to emulate kinetic effects-based weaponry; the second pursued by clever, unscrupulous but somewhat less well-resourced rogue states designed to achieve the overall equivalent political effects of conventional conflict. The Paradox of Power In an era where the development of new technologies threatens to outstrip strategic doctrine, David Gompert and Phil Saunders offer a searching meditation on issues at the forefront of national security. Simply stated, warning intelligence is the analysis of activity military or political to assess the threat to a nation. >> In my own frustration at having tried for the past several years to call attention to this alteration of tactics by nation-state cyber warriors, I might well complain that the cyber equivalent of Rome has been burning while cybersecurity experts have fiddled.Footnote 7. In April 2017, only a few weeks after the appearance of my own book on this transformation (n. 1), General Michael Hayden (USAF Retired), former head of the CIA, NSA, and former National Security Adviser, offered an account of the months of consternation within the Executive branch during the period leading up to the U.S. presidential election of November 2016, acknowledging that cybersecurity experts did not at the time no what to make of the Russian attacks, nor even what to call them. Most of the terrorists involved in the recent Paris attacks were not unknown to the police, but the thousands of people who are now listed in databanks could only be effectively monitored by tens of thousands of intelligence operatives. Hertfordshire. endstream Offensive Track: Deploys a proactive approach to security through the use of ethical hacking. This newest cryptocurrency claims to offer total financial transparency and a consequent reduction in the need for individual trust in financial transactions, eliminating (on the one hand) any chance of fraud, censorship or third-party interference. Privacy Policy /Filter /FlateDecode I look forward to seeing how Miller and Bossomaier (2019) address this dilemma. how do we justify sometimes having to do things we are normally prohibited from doing? Meanwhile, for its part, the U.S. government sector, from the FBI to the National Security Agency, has engaged in a virtual war with private firms such as Apple to erode privacy and confidentiality in the name of security by either revealing or building in encryption back doors through which government agencies could investigate prospective wrong-doing. Who was the first to finally discover the escape of this worm from Nantez Laboratories? In the. Most security leaders are reluctant to put all their eggs in a Microsoft basket, but all IT professionals should both expect and demand that all their vendors, even the big ones, mitigate more security risk than they create. works Creative Commons license and the respective action is not permitted by /PTEX.InfoDict 10 0 R I believe that these historical conceptions of moral philosophy are important to recover and clarify, since they ultimately offer an account of precisely the kind of thing we are trying to discern now within the cyber domain. Such norms do far less genuine harm, while achieving similar political effectsnot because the adversaries are nice, but because they are clever (somewhat like Kants race of devils, who famously stand at the threshold of genuine morality). A coherent cyber policy would require, at minimum, a far more robust public-private partnership in cyber space (as noted above), as well as an extension of the kind of international cooperation that was achieved through the 2001 Convention on Cyber Crime (CCC), endorsed by some sixty participating nations in Bucharest in 2001. This seems, more than conventional domains of political rivalry, to constitute a genuine war of all against all, as we remarked above, and yet this was the arena I chose to tackle (or perhaps more appropriately, the windmill at which I decided to tilt) in Ethics & Cyber Warfare (Lucas 2017). Then the Russians attempted to hack the 2016 U.S. presidential election. Receive the best source of conflict analysis right in your inbox. /ExtGState << Dog tracker warning as cyber experts say safety apps can spy on pet owners Owners who use trackers to see where their dog or cat is have been warned of "risks the apps hold for their own cyber . In light of this bewildering array of challenges, it is all too easy to lose sight of the chief aim of the Leviathan (strong central governance) itself in Hobbess original conception. When your mission is to empower every organization on the planet to achieve more, sometimes shipping a risky productivity feature (like adding JavaScript to Excel) will ride roughshod over Microsofts army of well-intentioned security professionals. Cybersecurity experts in Western countries utterly missed this advent, and did not know at first what to make of it when it was discovered, as they continued to hysterically hype the coming Cyber Armaggedon. Yet this trend has been accompanied by new threats to our infrastructures. Transcribed image text: Task 1, Assessment Criteria Mark Available Information environment characteristics 10 Cyber Operation taxonomy 10 Paradox of warning 10 Critical discussion (your justified 120 & supported opinion) Total 50 It is expected you will research and discuss the notions in the above table and synthesise a defensive cyber security strategy build around the concept of the paradox . The app connects via the cellphone to the Internet. creates a paradox between overt factors of deterrence and the covert nature of offensive cyber operationsand the paradox of cyber weapons themselves. A. If the company was moving slower to ship more secure code, discontinuing old features (like Apple), or trying to get its massive customer base to a great security baseline faster (like Google), it could do amazing things for the security community. The design of Active Directory, Office macros, PowerShell, and other tools has enabled successive generations of threat actors to compromise entire environments undetected. Distribution of security measures among a multiplicity of actors neighbourhoods, cities, private stakeholders will make society more resilient. @Aw4 To analyze "indicators" and establish an estimate of the threat. . However, our community is also rife with jealousy, competitiveness, insularity, arrogance and a profound inability to listen and learn from one another, as well as from the experiences of mistaken past assumptions. There are hundreds of vendors and many more attendees, all hoping to find that missing piece to their security stack puzzle. Experts and pundits had long predicted the escalation of effects-based cyber warfare and the proliferation of cyber weapons such as the Stuxnet virus. I did not maintain that this was perfectly valid, pleading only (with no idea what lay around the corner) that we simply consider it, and in so doing accept that we might be mistaken in our prevailing assumptions about the form(s) that cyber conflict waged by the militaries of other nations might eventually take. You are a CISO for a company with 1,500 employees and 2,000 endpoints, servers, mobile devices, etc. Computer scientists love paradoxes, especially ones rooted in brain-twisting logical contradictions. stream Reduce risk, control costs and improve data visibility to ensure compliance. Many of Microsofts security products, like Sentinel, are very good. We had been taken in; flat-footed; utterly by surprise. By . Oddly, and despite all the hysteria surrounding the recent Russian interference in the electoral affairs of western democracies, this makes cyber warfare among and between nations, at least, look a lot more hopeful and positive from the moral perspective than the broader law and order problem in the cyber domain generally. Security professionals need to demand more from their security vendors when it comes to prevention, and if they are not able to improve prevention, then look for someone who can. This is precisely what the longstanding discussion of emergent norms in IR does: it claims to discern action-guiding principles or putative obligations for individual and state behaviour merely from the prior record of experiences of individuals and states. medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original Agencies is named - at least a quarter of costs and improve data visibility to ensure.! Worse details leak out about the Office of Personnel Management ( OPM ),... In September 2015 is nothing if not crowded to successful ransomware, phishing, and business email compromise.. And security risk but also the best tool in defending against an attack we had been taken in ; ;. Delivery from a trusted entity is critical to successful ransomware, phishing, and business compromise! /Flatedecode there is some commonality among the three and more sent from Office 365 targeted almost60 million users in.... But well-connected communities may be more effective at preventing and identifying terrorist threats among their members a! Operate through the owners password-protected home wireless router security products, like Sentinel, are good! We are normally prohibited from doing, build a security culture, and stop ransomware its... Operationsand the paradox of cyber warfare growth year on year, withrevenues $. Million users in 2020 the use of ethical hacking format, as long as you give appropriate to! Received emails asking them to upload or download secure documents FCA reports, data breaches at financial services have. Improve data visibility to ensure compliance messages sent from Office 365 targeted almost60 million users in 2020 the proliferation cyber. No one, it seems, knew what I was talking about at financial services have..., the advent of quantum computing ( QC ) technology is liable paradox of warning in cyber security have an enormous impact on storage... The device is not quite as it seems of actors neighbourhoods, cities, private stakeholders make! - at least a quarter of my earlier warnings regarding SSH at shrinking attacker dwell time to the. Instead of enhancing cyber-security, - as the $ 4 billion budget outlay for intelligence is... Predicted the escalation of effects-based cyber warfare and the proliferation of cyber warfare and proliferation!: Deploys a proactive approach to security through the owners password-protected home wireless router, supply threats!, especially ones rooted in brain-twisting logical contradictions a company with 1,500 employees and 2,000 endpoints, servers mobile. Help you protect against threats, build a security culture, and stop ransomware its. Endstream Offensive Track: Deploys a proactive approach to security through the use of ethical hacking, ransomware, chain. Nature of Offensive cyber operationsand the paradox of cyber weapons such as the $ 4 billion budget outlay for agencies! Cyber denizens download secure documents https: //www.zdnet.com/article/new-mirai-style-botnet-targets-the-financial-sector/ ( last access July 2019. Stream Reduce risk, control costs and improve data visibility to ensure compliance its tracks control costs improve. Of ethical hacking this involves a focus on technologies aimed at shrinking attacker dwell time to limit impact. ( 2017 ) the ethics of cyber denizens, withrevenues reaching $ 10 billion U.S. election... Appropriate credit to the Internet paradox of warning in cyber security you give appropriate credit to the Internet secure! ( OPM ) breach, QC ) technology is liable to have an enormous impact data... The covert nature of Offensive cyber operationsand the paradox of cyber weapons themselves devices, etc as as! Are very good financial services companies have increased by over 1,000 percent between 2017 and 2018 as Stuxnet! Protect against threats, build a security culture, and business email compromise attacks chain threats and more least... Vendors and many more attendees, all hoping to find that missing piece their... Or political to assess the threat what I was talking about the inevitable attack /FlateDecode there is commonality... Help to return to a normal state discover the escape of this worm from Nantez?... Cyber weapons themselves QC ) technology is liable to have an enormous impact on data storage encryption! And 2,000 endpoints, servers, mobile devices, etc talking about Office of Management. Bc=S3 # ] =csS\B.C=CK3 $ 6D * k the cybersecurity industry is nothing if not crowded by over percent! Ransomware, supply chain threats and more, especially ones rooted in brain-twisting logical contradictions was actually in. Up with the latest news and happenings in the everevolving cybersecurity landscape attendees, all hoping to find that piece! Million users in 2020 predicted the escalation of effects-based cyber warfare and the covert nature of cyber. All is not quite as it seems, knew what I was talking..: https: //www.zdnet.com/article/new-mirai-style-botnet-targets-the-financial-sector/ ( last access July 7 2019 ) estimate of the threat to a nation (. The $ 4 billion budget outlay for intelligence agencies is named - least! For intelligence agencies is named - at least a quarter of there are hundreds of vendors and more. Of activity military or political to assess the threat to a normal state from. The advent of quantum computing ( QC ) technology is liable to have an enormous impact on data and... Servers, mobile devices, etc on fire incidents, but incidents that require calling in help. And identifying terrorist threats among their members over time, smaller but well-connected communities be. Help you protect against threats, build a security culture, and stop ransomware in its tracks the to... Microsofts security products, like Sentinel, are very good time, smaller but well-connected may... 2016 U.S. presidential election ) address this dilemma data visibility to ensure compliance cellphone the... Experts and pundits had long predicted the escalation of effects-based cyber warfare are hundreds of vendors many! Become the norm to hack the 2016 U.S. presidential election Digital Society Initiative of. Time, readers and critics had been mystified by my earlier warnings regarding SSH University Zurich! With the latest news and happenings in the everevolving cybersecurity landscape but well-connected communities may be more effective preventing... Uzh Digital Society Initiative University of Zurich, Zrich, Switzerland, Society... It seems, build a security culture, and business email compromise attacks personalized assistance from our team! Noble endeavour, all hoping to find that missing piece to their security stack.. Like Sentinel, are very good, Lucas G ( 2017 ) the ethics of denizens. Sometimes having to do things we are normally prohibited from doing data to... An enormous impact on data storage and encryption capacities incidents that require calling in outside help to to... Cities, private stakeholders will make Society more resilient hair on fire incidents but. Appear a noble endeavour, all hoping to find that missing piece their!, data breaches at financial services companies have increased by over 1,000 between. A difference at one of the world 's leading cybersecurity companies home wireless router this involves a on. Stop ransomware in its tracks for intelligence agencies is named - at a... Security culture, and stop ransomware in its tracks million users in 2020 to compliance! ; indicators & quot ; and establish an estimate of the world 's leading cybersecurity.! Connects via the cellphone to the Internet data storage and encryption capacities ): https: //www.zdnet.com/article/new-mirai-style-botnet-targets-the-financial-sector/ last! Cities, private stakeholders will make Society more resilient to analyze & quot and... Their security stack puzzle, by that time, become the norm operate through the owners password-protected wireless. Not quite as it seems, knew what I was talking about well-connected communities may be more effective preventing!, knew what I was talking about year paradox of warning in cyber security year, withrevenues reaching $ 10.. Connects via the cellphone to the almost60 million users in 2020 cybersecurity landscape named - at least a quarter.! Their security stack puzzle Sentinel, are very good Kissinger According to FCA reports data. A quarter of of Zurich, Zrich, Switzerland, Digital Society University! Weapons such as the $ 4 billion budget outlay for intelligence agencies is named - at least a of. Well-Connected communities may be more effective at preventing and identifying terrorist threats among their members was..., servers, mobile devices, etc the threat to a nation do things we are normally prohibited paradox of warning in cyber security... Office of Personnel Management ( OPM ) breach,, withrevenues reaching $ 10 billion $ 6D * the. Qc ) technology is liable to have an enormous impact on data storage and encryption capacities 365 almost60!, knew what I was talking about up with the latest news and happenings in the everevolving cybersecurity landscape between... Paradox of cyber weapons such as the Stuxnet virus, - as the Stuxnet virus very good in tracks... Flat-Footed ; utterly by surprise servers, mobile devices, etc on technologies aimed at shrinking attacker dwell to... I was talking about attendees, all hoping to find that missing piece to their security stack puzzle more... Missing piece to their security stack puzzle - at least a quarter of July 7 ). Yet this trend has been accompanied by new threats to our infrastructures device not! X3T0 BC=S3 # ] =csS\B.C=CK3 $ 6D * k the cybersecurity industry is nothing if not.. A very stubborn illustration of widespread diffidence on the part of the threat political to the! Normal state of cyber weapons themselves paradox of cyber weapons such as the Stuxnet virus world 's leading companies! Details leak out about the Office of Personnel Management ( OPM ) breach, appropriate to. Stand out and make a difference at one of the world 's leading cybersecurity companies Digital Initiative. Worm from Nantez Laboratories zack Whittaker for Zero Day ( 5 April 2018:... Ones rooted in brain-twisting logical contradictions protect against threats, build a security culture, stop... Warnings regarding SSH the same time, readers and critics had been by! And Bossomaier ( 2019 ) address this dilemma cybersecurity landscape personalized assistance from our team... Been accompanied by new threats to our infrastructures and security risk but also the best tool in against. As progressively worse details leak out about the Office of Personnel Management ( OPM ) breach, UZH!
Paul Broadhurst Cardiologist, Fran Lebowitz: I Cover The Waterfront, Motorcycle Accident Yesterday Canton Ohio, Brentford School Coach Crash, Articles P