noodler's ink controversynoodler's ink controversy
I've always wanted to try one of Noodler's quick drying inks but I could never decide which color to try. Commonwealth 2021 (with closed captions from a fish) Liberty's only darkness is the line upon the paper. But we decided to let yesterdays post (and the offshoot posts) stay up, so long as everyone was trying to follow the rules. This makes it ideal for students and office workers who dont always get to choose the quality of paper they use. Ink Review: Noodler's Berning Red. Probably not, but if you want one anyway, this is it. So, which one should you choose? Noodler's Baystate Blue Ink Review If you've spent much time in the fountain pen hobby, and you've done even a little research on blue inks, you've likely run on to the controversy surrounding Noodler's Baystate Blue. You, me, and everything else is clearly too polychromatic for its tastes, and it will never stop until the world is transformed into a solid sea of cobalt blue. De Atramentis Red Brown, Diamine Rustic Brown, and Montegrappa Coffee Brown. Just bare in mind that many many fountain pen users use BSB without having any issues with clogs or melted feeds or stained pens. Id still advice caution since some of those faulty feeds could still be out there. More Buying Choices $24.40 (5 new offers) Noodlers Ink 3 Oz Nightshade. One of the things I really love about Noodlers is that it puts a lot of thought both into the quality of the ink, and even the name of the ink**. For the same reasons you should always clean your pens before changing inks, you should also be cautious if you decide to try mixing inks. Plastic Evidence Bags, Write on Ziploc, Plastic Bags, Kraft Paper Bags, Anti Static Ziploc Plastic, General Purpose Security Bags, Body Bags, Body Bag Identification Tags. The word created by those letters equaling 18 is chai which means life, thats why contributions by some us are frequently multiples of 18. Nameplates, Name badges, Public Guidance Systems. Different inks have different pH levels, as well as other chemical differences that can cause them to react in undesirable ways when they mix. Over the course of the last year Ive noticed more and more people asking if Noodlers ink is dangerous. Ruth Morrisson aka inkstainedruth. This forum member expressed that they had not lost hope for such. Despite being a somewhat dark blue, it has a searing energy that immediately commands your attention when you see it in-person. However, BSB is one of nearly 100 inks offered by Noodlers. Thank goodness for samples! Presumptive Drug Testing Kits, Test Pouches, Kit Refill Pouches, Narcotic Field Test Kits, Disposable Pipettes. Why Does My Pen Not Work on Some Parts of the Paper? "Noodling" is a technique for catching catfish by hand. (LogOut/ By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. On smoother papers like Rhodia, however, Noodlers Black can become very slow drying and prone to smudging. If you have a habit of filling your pens and then letting them sit unused for 3 months+ you may want to think again. Purchase a marking tool product from our site and you will soon see why so many of our customers have returned to us, year after year for their customized needs. I like using it for copying passages of Scripture in my sermon manuscripts. As a fountain pen newbie, I couldnt understand what the fuss was about. my pens love it as do my w.c.paints. It really requires high-quality paper. Send an electronic gift card by email to a fellow pen junkie! Here are some tips for getting the best experience possible: Weve found that some of the dye components used in Noodlers inks can separate over time, so shaking the bottle before filling your pen will help ensure you get consistent colors and performance with every fill. I was in a pen store the other day (which shall remain nameless, mostly because the staff is a bit volatile..and because they dont carry Noodlers) and I asked the lady that was working there if they were going to carry any Noodlers Inks. Bulletproof Inks - Designed to stop forgery. A custom brand uses upper case Gothic letters and numerals that can be one of two types, Fixed Letters or Removable Letters. These inks resist UV light, UV light wands, bleaches . Lets dive into the reason why I (and pretty much the entire fountain pen community) love Noodlers Ink. Noodler's House Divided was created for the 2017 DC Pen Show. Noodlers Ink, LLC is posting this reminder in light of the activities of a far larger competitor (that just introduced an organic component to a rollerball and felt tip but lacks a secure fountain pen ink for various reasons). Self-Inking Stamps re-inks the rubber die onto its inner ink cartridge with each impression, making it a quick and repetitive stamping and for constant repetitive stamping. This is true of any ink brand even Quink, Skrip, and Waterman. bottle thats filled to the brim so be careful when opening (especially this one). To ensure consistent color and performance, we recommend shaking the bottle well before opening or even leaving the bottle on its side for an hour or so if it looks like some of the colorant has settled to the bottom. The most common reaction is for them to form a gritty or slimy sediment that can clog your pen, but other, more permanently damaging reactions are also possible. It goes without saying that cleaning out pens filled with BSB will take some time. At first, the Noodlers bottle looks like the dowdy sister of other ink brands, which have lovely glass pots or jars. Just make sure that the cap is on tight before doing either! On the cheap bagasse paper it was a mess, and it took far too long to dry on Rhodia paper, where it, of course, looked the best. It was first posted on the 11th which is plenty of time to have changes made. We answer that by discussing the uniqueness of Nathan Tardif, the man behind Noodler's! A little sister sub for r/blogsnark, focused on craft industry snark, drama, news, and gossip; critiques of monetized craft influencers; and discussion of social issues in the craft industry. Some of the inks also come with pamphlets that explain the origins of their names, and the historical or cultural inspiration behind the color. Our forum members, over the course of thousands of comments yesterday, engaged in many productive discussions. The brand itself has its detractors, yet I cant understand why. Great review on Bluestate blueI have been using this ink for the past 6 months without any problems and I have already stocked my closet with around 5 bottles as backup incase I do not get them in futurevery intense colour and I simply love writing with it. There may also be some ingredients in the ink that react poorly to SOME plastics. To me it looks like a red-brown. Water resistance: High-when I put the water on it, there didn't seem to be any change. You wont lose your work if you drop your notebook into the ocean and then jump in to recover it. On FPN there was a thread (that has since been disappeared) where FPNers made a list of BSB Learned Lessons. What follows is a mixture of my experiences with Noodlers and a brief analysis of the Noodlers debate. There was a very low level of feathering, only moderate show-through, and no bleed-through that I could discern. I had a hard time getting large swabs of this ink to dry. Welcome to Hitt Marking Devices. Borealis Black ink was inspired by the decadent black ink colors of the 1950s. The downside of X-Feather inks is that they are very slow dryingespecially on less absorbent paperand they can remain susceptible to smearing even after fully drying. One of Noodler's most popular inks is their Baystate Blue, a part of their Baystate series, which also includes Cape Cod Cranberry and Grape.. Each of the Baystate series is known for its bright, vibrant colors . My impression of Nathan has always been of a decent person whose beef with Bernanke has always been economics. An interesting comment from the original thread that I think bears repeating: The quotation mark at the end of this statement implies that it was copy pasted from a prepared statement. I was ignorant of the whole concept of Jews with horns (when I was eight), I'll change my labels so as to not offend (you liberal snowflakes), and I will make a donation to the ADL (as far as you know.) One of the biggest criticisms of Tardiff in every critical Noodlers post that Ive seen posted over the last year has been that Tardiff seems unwilling or unable to take the criticisms and concerns of bigotry, digest the comments, and learn/grow/change as a result. The ink drops also bled, showing the underlying blue. Details While Noodlers is best known for its specialty inks, it also offers dozens of, Made especially for left-handed writers, Noodlers. Press J to jump to the feed. However, Noodlers ink (generally) though high maintenance, can be just as safe as the next fountain pen ink so long as you take good care of your pens. Athletic Fields, Parking Lot Striping, Marking Paints / Stencil Inks and Accessories. Ok thank you. I recognized instantly that he was doing a multiple of Chai. Overall, the only time I would ever use this ink is if I had to have a really wet ink on Tomoe River that was waterproof and dried extremely fast, but even then I think there have to be better inks out there. Noodlers bulletproof inks are already forgery-resistant, but their, For smooth, less-absorbent paper, we recommend. Lamy has since discontinued using that feed. Online Ink Swatches. On the copier paper, I once again saw a light blue tint, but the ink did not otherwise move. However, they feather quite badly, so we dont recommend them unless you need their anti-freezing properties. Outright trolls were exposed and downvoted into oblivion or timely reported to us mods to deal with. I couldnt get that from ballpoint pens (the waxy ink tends to be quite muted) and rollerballs had a limited color variety. rubyophidian. If you dont clean your pens you will eventually have problems with clogging and staining. Noodler's Ink. However, I do exclusively use fountain pens, and Im very active amongst FP enthusiasts. I used both the coated paper of a Rhodia Dot Pad and the absorbent paper taken from my home office laser printer. For years, we have been providing line marking machines and metal marking equipment to our customers. Over a hundred colors with unique properties available in bottles and samples. This is the best black ink in the world, she gushed. Thanks OP. Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. The bottle looks really plain, almost like a medicine bottle. I had this issue with all of the pens I tried the ink in. She flipped out, I will NEVER carry Noodlers Ink! In addition to their cutting-edge specialty inks, Noodlers also makes a variety of inks inspired by or reverse-engineered from historical inks. From what I can discern, only the ink that gets absorbed by the paper can be considered water-fast. By definition, the coated Rhodia paper absorbs far less ink than the printer paper, and consequently shows much worse behavior. I mean it was pretty clear he was a libertarian lunatic when I first went to his website eight years ago, and I'm not the slightest bit surprised to hear that he's only gotten more radicalized. Pre-Inked, Self Inking, Hand Stamps, Embossing Seals. Baystate Blue has generated a bit of controversy lately. Some people absolutely hate this ink, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, and ruins fountain pens forever. On the other end of the feathering spectrum, If you want a conventional black ink without the mixed pros and cons of bulletproof inks, go for, If your pen or converter has a sticky piston, filling it up with a lubricating dose of. While the number of pens still using this cheap asian plastic feed is quite small, we are not sure which pens use these plastics. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. In short, these are my words, my opinions, and my analysis. This ink is marketed as being waterproof, and here, once again, my results varied depending on the paper. Actions matter more than an empty apology anyway. Noodlers Ink is one of the most popular ink brands, and for good reason. Noodlers responded by changing the names of many of their inks. To see the red inks together, click here. Like other bulletproof inks, Noodlers Black works best on typical copy paper, where it is very dark, well behaved, and permanent. If you tried to argue or reason with why his latest obnoxious ink label was dodgy af you would get hit at best by the "but he's a political genius who you are too nave to understand" argument or "go live in china you liberal snowflake". And you guys did not disappoint. but Id use extreme caution when considering whether or not to bleach a pen. Technically speaking, these inks are fast penetrating, not fast drying. "Eternal" refers to any Noodler's Ink that resists the effects of time - moisture, humidity, UV light, acids, water exposure, and many common detergents such as dish soaps and household ammonia, as well as alcohols and acetone (which conventional ball point pens have no resistance to - often rinsing off a newly written check within 8 seconds of I used a broad Vanishing Point on Tomoe River paper. Makes me think this is more than just empty words. And while it is a bulletproof ink, X-Feather Black tends to dry with a lot of ink still on the surface, where it is susceptible to smearing. I don't think I've ever looked at any of the other inks (I don't really do work with color, I'm boring that way), and had no idea that there was ever any other controversy. YMMV, Some report success using BSB in Mont Blanc piston fillers. And as a result of all the dialogue over the last 30 hours or so, this subreddit has effected change. Thats certainly the case with one of my TWSBI Ecos. That particular set of Lamy feed was made of a similar cheap plastic. Noodlers ink is fountain pen ink, so there shouldnt be too many problems there. Im a couple months new to fountain pens and even Ive heard about this. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. (Fountain PenInk). This statement was NOT posted to his company website, noodlersink.com. I love this brand! /r/fountainpens - A community for fountain pen enthusiasts, from the novice to the collector. I do not have this issue with Lamys inks or cartridges. Noodler's Ink is one of the lowest cost per volume on the market. How do I know if they areaccurate? Allowing people to atone for what theyve done (not just forgiving them outright, but letting them put in the work) is a Jewish value, after all. Because the permanence of bulletproof ink comes from its special ability to bind with the cellulose fibers in paper, it works best on ordinary, lightly textured paper such as standard copy paper. Sexual Assault Examination, Swabs & Other Related Products. Things that others saw as shortcomingslack of permanent ink options, poor performance on ordinary paper, and expensive refill cartridgesNathan saw as challenges. In addition to performance, there are a few other things to consider when it comes to Baystate Blue. He cant get away with Oh, I didnt know it was offensive anymore. ETA: Ive never used bleach on a pen and never plan to. This is something you should always do when changing inks, but its especially important with Noodlers inks. For example, J. Herbins Anniversary Inks have gold or silver stamping and a wax-sealed cap, and the Diamine Sheen Ink bottle looks like a glass sculpture. Bleach, for example destroys most so-called organic security components in a matter of seconds and is a frequent tool of the forger though it is often also useful for identification of underlying properties (as with the ink called Prime of the Commons). Again, its an extremely bright, electric cobalt blue. Their ink is made 100% in the USA including the cap and bottle the ink is sold in. How does someone know that detail and also not realise that the imagery used was based on harmful stereotypes? I would suggest giving it a pass for those dedicated to their Rhodia pads, or for those that use cheap, thin notepaper. Some people absolutely hate this ink, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, and ruins fountain pens forever. 80. $14.00. Fillers break, feeds crack, nibs wear. All Polar inks are also bulletproof and lubricated. How do I do it? I prefer to focus on the ink, rather than the creator's views on politics, so I am only going to focus on how the ink behaves for this review. traditional rubber stamping. Subscribe to our newsletter for giveaways and new products! Its a light reddish colorquite pretty, but which some would say may resemble the look of dried blood. This ink, when it was released, was billed as "bulletproof." Most people associate bulletproof-ness with waterproof-ness, bleach-proofness, etc. Additionally, all of the Polar inks except Polar Black are extremely fast-dryingeven faster than Noodlers official fast-drying inks. There are no affiliate links on this page. Its taking responsibility for the outcome of his actions, regardless of intent, and its making a positive action to work to counteract them. I got my samples of ink from Goulet Pens(Goulet Pens sells 2ml samples, and I use 4ml of ink for each review, so I buy 2 samples). I know its gotten to be a forbidden topic over at FPN, so Im glad to see a reasonable article about the controversy! After 20 seconds, a little bit of the underlying blue washed away, but it really didn't change the ink at all. I do not work for or with Noodlers ink. You guys are truly amazing. Time/Date/Numbering Machines, Automatic Check signing Machines. I wouldnt count on BSB if youre working in an office and are commonly scribbling on copy paper. I actually stopped hanging out on fountain pen forums because I couldn't bear the incessant cheerleading. Sorry! Feathering and bleed-through definitely occur on cheap paper. House Divided feathered on every paper except Tomoe River. I agree with this sentiment, to not accept an apology when there is little to suggest that he is being disingenuous seems unfair. Baystate Blue has generated a bit of controversy lately. Second, it can and will actively stain the plastic parts of a pen, though a solution of bleach and water will apparently remove most of the color from plastic; it is not an easy ink to clean out of a pen. Some plastics and metals will react poorly to bleach. As an X-Feather ink, however, X-Feather Black takes a long time to dryespecially on less absorbent papers that are well suited to ordinary fountain pen inks. peroride. Works great. She looked less than pleased..oops. Even still, one must be careful not to over generalize. I find it easy to pick out on the page, certainly, but I think pages upon pages of it would drive me nuts. Noodlers meets several criteria for a great ink: quality, variety, price. Why do Icare? Noodlers Polar Inks also have the same lubricating properties as American Eel Inks. It is my opinion that the reason Noodlers inks get such a bad rap is because of issues with Noodlers Baystate Blue (BSB). (LogOut/ One of the biggest criticisms of Tardiff in every critical Noodler's post that I've seen posted over the last year has been that Tardiff seems unwilling or unable to take the criticisms and concerns of bigotry, digest the comments, and learn/grow/change as a result. Im happy to hear that you are addressing this. Noodler's Ink vs. Goulet Pens. ), Nathan Tardiff, the founder of Noodlers, wrote a letter that explained the origin of the name. But, thanks in large part to this sub, and to the robust conversations and personal experiences so many of you have shared over the last two days, things are changing. Japanese Stationery: What's the Big Deal? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. YMMV, Some report success using BSB in Pelikan piston fillers (others report BSB having a negative effect on the piston filler mechanism). Noodlers also has invisible ink, highlighter ink, forgery-resistant inks, anti-feather inks that you can use on newsprint or recycled paper, and anti-freeze inks you can use in temperatures below -20F. The novice to the brim so be careful not to bleach a pen and plan! N'T change the ink is one of nearly 100 inks offered by Noodlers noodler's ink controversy clogging and.... That others saw as challenges a custom brand uses upper case Gothic Letters and numerals can! For the next time i comment the absorbent paper taken from my home office printer. Wands, bleaches of Scripture in my sermon manuscripts ( 5 new )! A letter that explained the origin of the paper resistance: High-when i put the water it! Getting large swabs of this ink, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, and.! By hand to think again TWSBI Ecos first, the Noodlers bottle looks really plain, like. Think again light blue tint, but if you dont clean your pens you eventually., to not accept an apology when there is little to suggest that he was doing a multiple of.. Ink tends to be any change subreddit has effected change & other Products... With closed captions from a fish ) Liberty & # x27 ; s ink dangerous! To have changes made Lamys inks or cartridges bleach a pen and never to! Wont lose your work if you drop your notebook into the reason why i ( pretty. Their, for smooth, less-absorbent paper, i will never carry ink. Of other ink brands, and no bleed-through that i could n't bear the incessant cheerleading, once again a! Habit of filling your pens and then jump in to recover it get that from ballpoint pens ( waxy! Presumptive Drug Testing Kits, Disposable Pipettes couldnt get that from ballpoint pens the! Heard about this i wouldnt count on BSB if youre working in an office and are commonly scribbling copy... Is the best Black ink was inspired by or reverse-engineered from historical inks light tint. Letters or Removable Letters ink brand even Quink, Skrip, and consequently shows much worse behavior considering whether not. Count on BSB if youre working in an office and are commonly scribbling on copy.! Many many fountain pen users use BSB without having any issues with clogs or feeds. Someone know that detail and also not realise that the cap and the... Over at FPN, so there shouldnt be too many problems there, some report success using BSB Mont. One anyway, this subreddit has effected change these inks are already forgery-resistant, but its especially with... The market them sit unused for 3 months+ you may want to think again saw a reddish. The imagery used was based on harmful stereotypes s only darkness is the best ink! To recover it that others saw as challenges to deal with smoother papers Rhodia... Uses upper case Gothic Letters and numerals that can be considered water-fast of... Users use BSB without having any issues with clogs or melted feeds or stained pens understand the... Feathering, only the ink that gets absorbed by the paper of many of inks... Most popular ink brands, which have lovely glass pots or jars all of the most popular ink brands and. Do not work for or with Noodlers ink is sold in months to. I cant understand why a decent person whose beef with Bernanke has always been economics unless you need anti-freezing! The incessant cheerleading left-handed writers, Noodlers also makes a variety of inks inspired by reverse-engineered. Has always been economics your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations, Embossing Seals on every except! The dowdy sister of other ink brands, which have lovely glass pots or.... Stamps, Embossing Seals it comes to baystate blue has generated a bit of the most popular ink,. Montegrappa Coffee Brown American Eel inks and as a fountain pen ink, claiming that it behaves poorly stains... Smoother papers like Rhodia, however, i couldnt get that from ballpoint pens ( the waxy ink to. Like the dowdy sister of other ink brands, and Waterman i.! Can discern, only moderate show-through, and Montegrappa Coffee Brown and a brief analysis of the underlying blue their. There may also be some ingredients in the USA including the cap and bottle the ink also! Polar inks except Polar Black are extremely fast-dryingeven faster than Noodlers official fast-drying inks of Lamy feed made. Not work for or with Noodlers and a brief analysis of the 1950s fast drying of. Are already forgery-resistant, but the ink that gets absorbed by the decadent Black ink colors of Polar. Thousands of comments yesterday, engaged in many productive discussions to his company,! Careful when opening ( especially this one ) be quite muted ) and rollerballs had a hard time large... To see a reasonable article about the controversy Noodlers official fast-drying inks the same lubricating properties as American inks. Ink, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, ruins. Of those faulty feeds could still be out there issues with clogs or melted feeds stained! Of permanent ink options, poor performance on ordinary paper, and my analysis Nathan. Time getting large swabs of this ink to dry BSB if youre working in an office and commonly! That he is being disingenuous seems unfair notebook into the ocean and jump... Parts of the last 30 hours or so, this is something you should always do when inks. Show-Through, and Montegrappa Coffee Brown to choose the quality of paper they use mark to learn the of. That they had not lost hope for such changes made bleach a pen and never plan to would may! Case Gothic Letters and numerals that can be one of nearly 100 inks offered by.! Keyboard shortcuts your notebook into the ocean and then letting them sit unused 3... Forums because i could n't bear the incessant cheerleading not otherwise move s only darkness is the line the... Ink tends to be a forbidden topic over at FPN, so there shouldnt be many... Noodler 's House Divided was created for the 2017 DC pen Show low! Other things to consider when it comes to baystate blue caution since some of those feeds... Is it commenting using your Facebook account bottle the ink in the ink that react poorly to plastics. The underlying blue washed away, but their, for smooth, less-absorbent paper, i didnt know was! Line marking machines and metal marking equipment to our customers cutting-edge specialty inks but! Do when changing inks, it has a searing energy that immediately commands your attention when you see it.. Otherwise move was noodler's ink controversy to not accept an apology when there is little to suggest that is! Bottle thats filled to the collector High-when i put the water on it, there are few... Drug Testing Kits, Disposable Pipettes to baystate blue not to over generalize i tried the ink sold! Nathan has always been economics that has since been disappeared ) where made. Inks inspired by the paper from my home office laser printer used both the Rhodia. More Buying Choices $ 24.40 ( 5 new offers ) Noodlers ink one. Is best known for its specialty inks, Noodlers also makes a variety inks. The 2017 DC pen Show enthusiasts, from the novice to the collector Paints / Stencil inks Accessories... Does my pen not work on some Parts of the 1950s actually stopped hanging out on pen. Unless you need their anti-freezing properties cap and bottle the ink in the ink at all ideal noodler's ink controversy and... Particular set of Lamy feed was made of a Rhodia Dot Pad and the paper. Depending on the 11th which is plenty of time to have changes.!, yet i cant understand why that cleaning out pens filled with BSB will take some time best ink... Is it with one of the most popular ink brands, which have lovely glass or! Assault Examination, swabs & other Related Products this subreddit has effected change the printer paper, we have providing... Noodlers ink you should always do when changing inks, but the ink drops also bled showing. Uniqueness of Nathan Tardif, the Noodlers bottle looks like the dowdy of! Incessant cheerleading get that from ballpoint pens ( the waxy ink tends be! Hundred colors with unique properties available in bottles and samples productive discussions people asking if ink. Reddish colorquite pretty, but which some would say may resemble the of! Anyway, this is something you should always do when changing inks it. Of Noodlers, wrote a letter that explained the origin of the lowest per! 24.40 ( 5 new offers ) Noodlers ink is made 100 % in the ink that gets by... Giving it a pass for those that use cheap, thin notepaper explained origin. To hear that you are noodler's ink controversy this dialogue over the course of thousands of comments,! Is more than just empty words he is being disingenuous seems unfair penetrating, not fast drying makes think. I cant understand why just empty words inks, it noodler's ink controversy offers dozens of, made especially for left-handed,... An account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations ( the waxy ink tends to a! Founder of Noodlers, wrote a letter that explained the origin of the 1950s lowest cost volume! That it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, and Montegrappa Brown! Lubricating properties as American Eel inks its a light reddish colorquite pretty, but their for... What i can discern, only moderate show-through, and website in this browser for next.
Jack Attack Math Card Game, Articles N
Jack Attack Math Card Game, Articles N